Stop and count to 10
My new obsession has been with the Way of the Master website. Kirk Cameron and Ray Comfort are just so enjoyably stupid, and provide such a wealth of material for a reasonable person to tap dance on that I just can’t help myself, for example let’s look at the following 10 commandments quiz.
It is entitled ARE YOU A GOOD PERSON?
“Almost everyone thinks they are a good person…but the question you should be asking is, ‘am I good ENOUGH to go to Heaven?’ How would you know?
The way to find out is to ask yourself if you have obeyed the 10 commandments. Most people say ‘Well I’ve broken one or two, but nothing too serious, like murder, etc.’ so let’s go through them and see how you do…”
1. You shall have no other God before me
“Have you ALWAYS put God first in your life? Jesus said to love God with all your heart and mind and soul and strength — so much, that your love for your parents, brothers, and sisters, friends and even your own life is like hatred compared to your love and devotion for God. Have you EVER failed to put Him first in your life?” Now I don’t remember hearing ‘love God like you hate everyone else’, I recall a nifty little B-side number called ‘love your neighbor as you love god’, I think that might have been off one of the two albums that went Gold.
2. You shall not make for yourself any idol.
“Who is God to you? Is he only a God of love and mercy who would never judge anyone and never cast anyone into Hell? If that is your god, then you’re right. Your god couldn’t cast anyone into Hell because he doesn’t exist. He is a figment of your imagination. You’ve created a god in your own mind that you’re more comfortable with. You may call it your “personal belief” but God calls it idolatry. It’s the oldest sin in the book, and the Bible warns that idolaters will not inherit the kingdom of Heaven.” Actually Idols are artistic images which are elevated to the status of God, artistic images like a sculpture, or a painting, or a book. Idol worship is when you cease to be inspired by an image, and start to become distracted by it, until eventually you are only worshiping the image as God or the word of God as the case may be. Oh and the oldest sin in the book, other than eating the fruit of the tree of knowledge (which I suppose would be coveting, then stealing), is murder (see Cable v. Abel)
3. You shall not take the name of God in vain.
“Have you ever used God’s name as a curse word? If you have, you’ve taken the holy name of God– who gave you your life, your family, and everything precious to you– and used it as a filthy, 4-letter word. Hitler’s name wasn’t even despised enough to be used as a curse word! If you have used God’s holy name in that manner, you are a blasphemer and the Bible says “God will not hold him guiltless who takes the name of the Lord in vain.” I have never used God’s name in vain, and I’ll bet you haven’t either, because God’s name is Yahweh. I’m not really sure which God they’re referring to because there is no 4-letter Judeo/Christian title for God. Maybe they mean Zeus, or Odin?
4. Remember the Sabbath Day, to keep it holy.
“God commands that we set aside one day in seven. Have you ever been guilty of breaking this Commandment?” These are the people who usually want you to give up your Sunday morning, your ONE AND ONLY MORNING TO SLEEP IN, so that you can drag your tired over worked ass to church, and NOW they’re big on you relaxing and having a Kit Kat (which was broken for you and many for the remission of Sin)
5. Honor your father and your mother.
“Have you ALWAYS honored your parents in a way that’s pleasing in the sight of God? Ask Him to remind you of the sins of your youth. You may have forgotten them but God hasn’t.” Wait a minute 4 Commandments ago they were telling us to hate our parents so that we can love God more. This is starting to feel like the mine field in the DMZ between North and South Korea.
6. You shall not murder.
“Jesus warned ‘Whoever is angry with his brother without cause, is in danger of judgment,” (Mat 5:22) and the Bible says, “He who hates his brother is a murderer,” (1 Jn 3:15) God sees hatred in the heart to be as wicked as murder. We can violate His Law by attitude and intent.” If we are guilty of breaking this commandment without breaking it, then why bother with restraint. I can think of two people who make me angry enough to take the plunge, like a hair club for men member, with total confidence.
7. You shall not commit adultery.
“Jesus warned, ‘You have heard…You shall not commit adultery, but I say to you that whoever looks at a woman to lust for her has already committed adultery with her in his heart.’ Have you ever looked at another person with lust? The Bible says that adulterers and fornicators (those who have sex before marriage) will not enter the kingdom of heaven.” This is the opposite of the cheaters assertion that an affair was just physical, and that they didn’t cheat in their heart. I don’t know if I buy either one. Jesus does say this in the Gospels but it’s hard for me to think of the socks under beds in dormitories as being the hardened remnants of adultery. If God didn’t want us to fiddle with our joystick or double click our mouse, you think he would have made our arms shorter. Think about it, actually no, don’t think, stand up. Now move your arms around in front of your genitals. See; just long enough. What does that tell YOU? Evolution rules!
8. You shall not steal.
Have you ever stolen anything (even if it was something small)? The value of the thing stolen doesn’t matter; petty theft is STILL theft. Have you ever taken anything that belonged to someone else (from the office, school, parents, etc.)? If you have, that makes you a thief.” I’ve stolen glances, I’ve stolen a heart or two, and I’ve even been accused of stealing the spotlight from time to time, do they count, you assholes? (Oh, oh I’m breaking the 6th commandment in my head again.)
9. You shall not lie.
“Have you ever told a lie? Then you are a liar. How many murders do you have to commit to be a murderer? Just one. If you have told even one lie, that makes you a liar. The Bible warns that ALL LIARS will have their part in the Lake of Fire (Rev 21:8) you may not think deceitfulness is a serious sin, but God does.” When I was growing up my dad used to watch wrestling with us on TV. Now every so often there would be a Saturday Night Main Event that would air at 11:30 PM and on the Saturdays when this would happen, dad would make this…food…stuff. It was kinda like chili only it had half cooked potatoes and frozen vegetable mix in it, and the meat in it were these great big chunks of sausage instead of ground beef. It was…it was just…just horrible, stuff, but my brother and my sister and I would pretend to like it because our dad had made it just for us, on our special night, and it made him happy. But I guess Kirk and Ray are right; we were just a pack of fucking liars.
10. You shall not covet.
“This means we should never desire anything that belongs to another person. Not their house, nor their car, nor their money, nor their wife, nor their lifestyle, nor anything that belongs to our neighbor.” Even if the thing I covet is the strength not to hate the likes of these two nut polyps?
The Way of the Master quiz is a wacky fun little device that allows Kirk and Ray to indiscriminately label every person who takes it as a sinner destined for hell, unless they jump on the Jesus band wagon. Now this is not an unfounded approach to Christianity, indeed it was quite the norm for hundreds of years, but it’s kind of the religious equivalent to using ‘thou’ and ‘thee’ in daily conversation, both antiquated and obsolete.
That being said; the element of this quiz that irritates me the most is that they leave out words for some of the commandments. Now call me a stickler, but if I’m being condemned to eternal damnation over a set of rules written in stone (both literally and figuratively) then God damn it (whoops! There goes #3) I would just as soon we got the complete text of the rules. I know it’s legalistic, but these are supposed to be laws and everyone is entitled to a public defender.
“I am the LORD your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. You shall have no other gods before me.”
It seems clear that complete obedience is required because the intended worshipers were brought out of slavery in the land of Egypt, allowing for a little theological quid-pro-quo if you will. Now, my family is Irish, and was never held in bondage by Pharaoh. Our Celtic ancestors were occasionally tortured into converting by Roman Christians though, so I think me and mine and everyone else who has an ancestor who was tortured in the name of this God, get a pass. I believe in God because I believe, not because I have to. I also can’t help but wonder why people who worship God as Three distinct individuals would want attention drawn to this declaration of monotheism. The Commandment for modern Christians reads much more like:
You shall have no other gods before me, or my son, or our Spirit, or his mother (Catholics only), or our 19th Century Prophet (Mormons only),
Trinitarian theology is in absolutely no way monotheistic. It is far more akin to the polytheism of Egypt, where the lesser divinities where conceptualized as aspects of the greater.
“You shall not make for yourself a graven image, or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; you shall not bow down to them or serve them; for I the LORD your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, but showing steadfast love to thousands of those who love me and keep my commandments.
The Renaissance was an abomination which lit the pilot light for Hell’s furnace according to this commandment. So too is every preschool arts and crafts room, topiary garden, and church containing crucifixes, icons, and stain glass windows. This is one of my favorite Commandments because this is the one that proves that they were written or compiled AFTER the original ‘Book of J’. In Chapter 21 of the Book of Numbers there is a story about the 40 years in the Wilderness in which the Children of Israel are being bitten by poisonous snakes. In order to save those who were dying of the bites, Moses cast an image of a serpent attached to a stick in bronze, which we are told caused those who looked upon it to be healed. This is certainly some kind of remnant of a cultic practice of ancient Israel that became taboo after the Babylonian exile, and since it treats a violation of the 2nd commandment as a celebrated cultural milestone we must assume that the story is earlier than the rule that developed forbidding the practice.
Additionally there is the notion that the all powerful God of the universe is consumed by an emotion as small and petty as jealousy. I can honestly say that I very rarely feel jealous any more. I have just about conquered this state of indulgent insecurity, am I to believe that I have emotionally evolved beyond God? Is God really just Jennifer Aniston giving the “Wife, Mother, and Humanitarian of the Year” Oscar to Angelina Jolie?
“You shall not take the name of the LORD your God in vain; for the LORD will not hold him guiltless who takes his name in vain.
Here we have God stipulating that his number is only given out in an emergency. It’s telling us that invoking God for support in petty human vanities is a no-no. When this commandment became associated with cursing, it was in a magical sense; God cannot be invoked to hex an enemy. Since casting hexes has fallen out of fashion here are some modern examples of vainly using God’s name:
God Damn it
God will damn you
God tells me I’m right, it’s in the Bible
God hates fags
God end abortion
God will destroy our enemies
God will get you on Judgment Day
“Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days you shall labor, and do all your work; but the seventh day is a Sabbath to the LORD your God; in it you shall not do any work, you, or your son, or your daughter, your manservant, or your maidservant, or your cattle, or the sojourner who is within your gates; for in six days the LORD made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that is in them, and rested the seventh day; therefore the LORD blessed the Sabbath day and hallowed it.
Go back to the quiz and you’ll see that they left out the part that identifies which day the Sabbath is on. The Sabbath day is Saturday (the 7th day of the week), which makes the Christian Sabbath of Sunday (the 1st day of the week) a violation, unless it is being used in addition to the day prescribed by God. At no point in the Bible does either God or Jesus say that the Sabbath was moved to the first of the week (Sunday), which makes every Christian who goes to church on Sunday and the mall on Saturday, a vile apostate sinner who should meet the working ends of an angry mob’s stoning rocks.
“Honor your father and your mother, that your days may be long in the land which the LORD your God gives you.
Did you catch that last part; the part that has the reason why you should honor your father and mother? With the complete sentence this commandment makes perfect sense, and seems decidedly less arbitrary. The vine of culture can only take root if planted in soil of the past. History unifies people, which is particularly seen in a culture that identifies present nationality after ancestral heritage, for instance I’m Irish/Canadian, Tony Danza is Italian/American, etc. (I know that you probably got my meaning after the first example I just desperately wanted to mention Tony Danza at some point. It has been on my mind since the beginning, and I am hoping I now can move on.) The 5th commandment is trying to insure that the children of Israel maintained their cultural identity, by ensuring that they were honoring father and mother or more accurately forefather and mother. The Romans invoked the customs of the ancestors in matters of ceremony; Americans refer to their founding fathers while trying to determine framers intent in constitutional maters; the children of Israel pled the 5th.
“You shall not kill.
“You shall not commit adultery.
“You shall not steal.
They managed not to omit anything from these three commandments, I imagine largely because they are only thirteen words altogether. They are also relatively straightforward, except that it should be noted that “committing adultery” meant that a married woman could not have sex outside of her marriage…because her husband owned her. On the other hand, a married man could fuck anything that moved except:
A married woman
A relative
His mother-in-law
An ox
A man
Everything else was fair game though.
“You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.
The difference between bearing false witness against your neighbor and lying is the difference between contempt of court and being a dick. Both juxtapositions are given their context by procedure. The 9th commandment is about falsely accusing ones neighbor of violating the law. It is the reduction and re-codification of a sequence of about 8 laws in the Code of Hammurabi concerning false accusations and their punishments. Absolute truth in conversations is not a mark to set for oneself.
Just imagine the number of inane conversations you have had in your life, and then imagine what the outcome would have been if you had told each of the people you were having those inane conversations with, that you thought they were utter shit, and that they would have to spend the whole of their natural lives in deep, deep study just to reach stupid, and how you wished and prayed that you had a Phillips head screwdriver in your hand so you could plunge it up your nose, swirl it around a little and pluck the memory of speaking to somebody so mired in idiocy out of your head. Now are these truths that should be shared? NO! Does the 9th commandment tell me I have to share them? NO!
“You shall not covet your neighbor’s house; you shall not covet your neighbor’s wife, or his manservant, or his maidservant, or his ox, or his ass, or anything that is your neighbor’s.”
What strikes me first about this commandment is that it makes the prohibition on theft irrelevant. One only steals what they first have coveted. To me #10 seems more like good friendly advice, then strict punitive law. You shouldn’t covet what other people have, not for moral reasons but because it’ll drive you crazy. There will always be something else that someone else has, that you will want. The world is currently crumbling economically because people coveted their neighbor’s houses and got mortgages they couldn’t afford, by banks who were coveting their competitor’s stock value and were therefore willing to finance anything for anyone. So as a piece of wisdom I give the 10th a 10, but as a law? What are the things that cannot be coveted?
House,
Wife,
Manservant (slave),
Maidservant (slavette),
Ox,
Ass (slavette?),
Or anything else.
This is a list of a person’s (man’s) likely assets. It is a property list in order of value; wife is less then house, livestock is less then slaves, female slaves are less then male slaves. I’m going to go out on a limb here and say that maybe, just maybe, this law is a little out of date.
Isn’t that really at the heart of the entire argument? We have laws in our society, laws that encompass every aspect and spirit of those Commandments which do not involve faith. They are more or less the basis for our notion of criminality, and that is how they have contributed to our morality. Outside of that, they are relics. They do not present a picture of God’s standard of righteousness they present a picture of the Children of Israel’s standard of civility. The Commandments were the links of the chains binding THEIR ancient society, but not ours; we have the wisdom of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, or the Bill of Rights if you are American. We have no need for this condensed Code of Hammurabi steakette, served with a side of religious intolerance.
Kirk and Ray quote the words of Jesus frequently in their quiz, yet they omit my favorite of his commentaries on the old law, and they do so because it invalidates their reasoning for using the commandments to threaten people into going to church. Jesus said that all the laws and the prophets could be reduced to two golden rules
Love the Lord your God with all your heart and mind and soul and spirit.
And
Love your neighbor as yourself.
If God is everywhere in the natural world, as we are told (split a piece of wood and I am there, lift a stone and you will find me) then to love God is to love and nurture the world, and creatures around you. If you have disrespect for science, you can never have a true appreciation or love for nature, and therefore God. If you develop quizzes to prove that everyone around you is going to hell unless they do what you say, then you are displaying hatred for your neighbors.
Kirk and Ray are assholes. Be nice, give a hoot, and you’ll be fine.